Business Insurance

Financial Claims Unplugged – October, 2026

This Month’s Topic –Employment Litigation in the “Country of California”

 

Despite reforms, PAGA (Private Attorney General Act) litigation in California continues to loom over senior leaders of employers. 

  • 1,955 Paga lawsuits filed in 2026
  • $545.4M total amount paid in damages as part of settlements in 2026
  • $1.62B fees plaintiff attorneys realized from PAGA litigation.

What’s Happening

To resolve complaints over alleged abuses of PAGA as it relates to alleged wage & hour law violations. Reforms were introduced, including limiting standing requirements to be able to bring such claims, allowing smaller businesses the opportunity to cure non-compliance, as well as setting a statute of limitations to make sure claims are made in a timely manner. Despite the intent of these reforms, it has failed to stem the tide of PAGA claims.

Who is being affected

If you’re an employer in California, or a non-California based employer but have employees in California, claims may be made against you under PAGA.

The trickle down

Plaintiff’s counsel is motivated to pursue PAGA claims, with the average attorney fee award in successful matters being $1,629,524. Companies have spent millions of dollars defending themselves against such allegations as combing through voluminous documents can be labor intensive and thus very expensive.

The Unplugged Take

The plaintiff’s bar in California is at the forefront of most litigation trends in the employment practices arena. Wage & Hour claims brought under PAGA, even in light ofreforms to the statute, have proliferated. You may receive aggressive notices from such firms despite full compliance. Be sure your payroll records are up to date.

Questions worth asking

Review your current program and consider these questions.

  1. Do you have an employment practices exposure in California, even if your company is not based there?
  2. Do you purchase a stand-alone employment practices liability insurance policy?
  3. Does that policy include defense costs coverage for Wage & Hour claims?
  4. If you do have Wage & Hour coverage, is there a California exclusion?

 

Claims Radar

 

Employment Practices

Website Accessibility Claims Continue to Rise in CA.
There has been a steady increase over the past several years in claims brought by customers under the Americans with Disability Act alleging a company’s website is not compliant with the ADA as it does not recognize website reading software used by the visually impaired.

Consider: Does your Employment Practices Liability policy provide coverage for discrimination claims brought by non-employees?

Cyber

California’s Attempts To Reign In CIPA Litigation.
The California legislature have voted in favor of a bill that would provide that the California Attorney General (AG) becomes the exclusive civil enforcer for the specified §638.51 (California Penal Code Section 638.51 makes it illegal to install or use a pen register or a trap and trace device without a valid court order or specific statutory exception) claims arising from conduct occurring on an internet website, online application, or mobile application.

Consider: Does your website have compliant consent banners on your page which allows visitors to opt out?

Fiduciary

9th Circuit Holds ERISA Does Not Preempt State Law Claims.
The Ninth Circuit panel held that ERISA did not preempt—and therefore did not require dismissal of a negligent misrepresentation claim arising from the plan administrator’s alleged misrepresentations to an out-of-network medical provider inquiring about the plan’s coverage rate for a patient’s upcoming surgery.

Consider: Federal laws and statutes usually set a floor for standards, while state laws may be more stringent. Is your Plan compliant with state laws?

Directors and Officers

Derivative Lawsuit Stems From Fines For Data Privacy Violations.
Shareholders filed a derivative lawsuit in federal court in California against the board of directors alleging breach of fiduciary duty in connection with fines assessed against the company. The shareholders allege the board failed to implement meaningful corrective measures despite being repeatedly fined for data privacy violations.

Consider: Does your company have robust protocols regarding data privacy and cyber security?

Insurance Coverage

Policyholders May Seek Relief Against Excess Insurers Prior To Exhaustion Of Underlying Layers.
The California Supreme Court held that an insured need not plead actual exhaustion of underlying insurance to pursue declaratory relief or bad faith theories against an excess insurer. The 50-page decision will likely bring excess insurers into coverage litigation before the underlying layer is exhausted.

Consider: How does the underlying insurance exhaustion wording red in your policies?

Let’s Talk

Bring Us the Question That Matters Most.

Financial Claims Unplugged is published monthly by the Relation Financial Lines Group. If one of these topics lands with you, your Relation team is ready to walk through what your program does — and does not — cover.