Employee Benefits

You Review Your 401(k). Who Reviews Your Health Plan?

BY  Dave Shirley   National Practice Leader, Employee Benefits

A large employer with 40,000 employees showed us how its broker had chosen the employer’s pharmacy benefit manager. The broker had sent each bidder a question-and-answer form and compared the answers. We asked how the employer knew it had gotten a good deal.

“We have no idea,” they told us. “We have absolutely no clue whether we really did or not.”

I recognized the process. I was using it ten years ago. No 401(k) committee would call that a fee review.

Your 401(k) Already Has a Process.

A retirement plan committee puts someone in charge of vendors. It documents its fee decisions and goes back to market on a set schedule.

In a 2010 fee-disclosure rulemaking, the Department of Labor assumed plans generally would request proposals every three to five years. In George v. Kraft Foods, the Seventh Circuit reversed summary judgment on a recordkeeping-fee claim because expert testimony about the lack of competitive bids could support a finding of imprudence. The case later settled for $9.5 million.

Regular bids help fiduciaries check whether fees are still reasonable and whether the vendor is meeting its contract. Health plans rarely get that treatment. I see health-plan reviews pushed to renewal, when time is short and the priority is keeping coverage in place. Employers just want to kick the can down the road.

Self-Funded Plans Put More on the Employer.

ERISA defines fiduciaries by function. A person is a fiduciary to the extent they exercise discretionary authority over plan management, control plan assets or have discretionary responsibility for plan administration. Fiduciaries must act in participants’ interests, pay only reasonable plan expenses and use the care of a prudent expert.

The Department of Labor says most employers that sponsor fully or partly self-funded plans exercise some of that discretion, which makes them fiduciaries. Some of the responsibility can sit with an administrator. In my experience, nine times out of 10 it stays with the employer.

Fully insured employers have fewer duties. They choose and monitor the insurer, handle employee contributions, send required notices and keep the plan document current.  This article applies to private-sector plans covered by ERISA. Public-sector and church plans follow different rules.

Recent Cases and New PBM Rules.

In 2024, employees sued Johnson & Johnson and Wells Fargo. They said each company let its pharmacy benefit manager overcharge the health plan or its members for prescription drugs. Both cases were thrown out because the judges found the employees hadn’t shown a personal financial loss. The Wells Fargo court dismissed the case a second time in March 2026. The plaintiffs in both cases have appealed.

I think employees are going to ask the same question about their health plan that they ask about their 401(k): “Are you really shopping and getting what’s best for me?”

JPMorgan employees got further. In March 2026, a federal judge allowed them to pursue prohibited-transaction claims over the company’s arrangement with CVS Caremark, while dismissing their separate fiduciary-duty claims. The complaint alleges Caremark raised prices on 366 generic drugs by an average of 211%. The court has not decided whether those allegations are true. Under Cunningham v. Cornell, a unanimous 2025 Supreme Court decision, defendant fiduciaries in a case like this bear the burden of proving that an ERISA exemption applies.

The Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2026, signed February 3, changes PBM contracts for ERISA plans. PBMs will have to pass through 100% of rebates and similar payments and send drug-spending reports at least every six months. Detailed reports go to plans offered by employers averaging at least 100 employees and to certain other plans with at least 100 participants. All plans receive summary reports; qualifying large fully insured plans may elect to receive the detailed version. For calendar-year plans, the requirements generally begin in 2029, depending on when the PBM contract was signed or renewed.

In January 2026, the Labor Department proposed a rule that would require PBMs, and some brokers and consultants connected to them, to tell self-funded plans twice a year how they’re paid and let plans audit those disclosures. The final rule hasn’t been published yet.

Once the law’s reporting requirements take effect, plans will receive PBM reports at least twice a year. Someone has to read them and call the PBM when the figures don’t match the contract.

“When you’re self-funded, you should have access to all this data. That should be a given.” — Dana Neighbors, Vice President, National Client Services, Employee Benefits

How to Review Health Plan Vendors.

Federal guidance for health plans calls for a formal review process at reasonable intervals. It recommends comparing information from providers on the same basis and documenting why a vendor was chosen. It also says plans should monitor providers after they are hired. In my experience, that just isn’t on employers’ minds. For a company with a few hundred employees, start by assigning an owner and deciding what that person or group oversees.

The owner’s first job is to write down who the plan’s named fiduciary is and which decisions have been handed to vendors. Give the committee or executive a short charter and set a meeting schedule that fits the plan calendar, including renewal. Keep minutes of what was decided and what’s still open. The minutes should also show when the plan last went to market and why it kept or replaced each vendor.

Since December 2021, brokers and consultants who reasonably expect at least $1,000 in direct or indirect compensation for services to an ERISA-covered health plan have had to disclose it to the plan’s responsible fiduciary. Read those disclosures and ask advisors and vendors how they’re paid, including whether any payment is tied to prescriptions or changes when plan costs rise.

Federal law bars health plans from signing contracts that block access to de-identified claims data or provider-specific cost and quality information, and plans must attest to compliance each year. Ask in writing what claims data and reports are available and how often they arrive. Ask, too, whether an independent analyst can receive the data under applicable privacy rules. Keep the answers on file.

Start With Pharmacy.

Pharmacy is a good place to test a plan’s oversight because the contract often contains pricing commitments that can be checked against claims. The discount off average wholesale price is only one part of what the plan pays. A 2025 Federal Trade Commission report found the three largest PBMs and their affiliated pharmacies earned more than $7.3 billion above acquisition cost on specialty generic drugs from 2017 to 2022, with some drugs marked up more than 1,000%. Committees should also understand rebates, fees, spread pricing and formulary terms, along with whether members can get the medications they need. “Pharmacy benefit managers get a bad rap because their pricing isn’t transparent,” says Dana Neighbors, Vice President, National Client Services, Employee Benefits at Relation Insurance. “The client doesn’t understand it.”

At Relation, we use an online auction, Relation Rx (powered by Truveris), built on the employer’s claims data from its current PBM. Each bidder prices the same prescriptions and states its discount off the average wholesale price for generic, brand-name and specialty drugs. After the contract starts, we check each quarter whether the PBM delivered what it promised. The committee can then question any gap between the contract and the claims.

The employer’s answer was honest: it didn’t know whether its broker’s process produced a good deal. Your health plan also has people making decisions in the company’s name.  You should be able to say who they are and how the plan checks their work. If you can’t, start by naming an owner for the review.

TAKE THE NEXT STEP

Ready to review your policy, identify gaps, and proactively manage your employee benefits risk?

Let’s get started.

Dave Shirley, National Practice Leader, Employee Benefits
[email protected]

SOURCES
[1] U.S. Department of Labor, “Reasonable Contract or Arrangement Under Section 408(b)(2) Fee Disclosure,” 75 Fed. Reg. 41600 (July 16, 2010); NAPA, “Case of the Week: RFP Every Three?” May 2024; George v. Kraft Foods Global, Inc., No. 10-1469 (7th Cir. 2011); PLANSPONSOR, “Settlement Entered in Kraft Excessive Fees Case,” March 7, 2012. https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2010/07/16/2010-16768/reasonable-contract-or-arrangement-under-section-408b2-fee-disclosure ; https://www.napa-net.org/news/2024/5/case-week-rfp-every-three/ ; https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/ca7/10-1469/10-1469-2011-04-11-opinion-2011-04-11.html ; https://www.plansponsor.com/settlement-entered-in-kraft-excessive-fees-case/ [2] 29 U.S.C. § 1002(21)(A). https://uscode.house.gov/view.xhtml?req=granuleid:USC-prelim-title29-section1002 [3] 29 U.S.C. § 1104(a)(1). https://uscode.house.gov/view.xhtml?req=granuleid:USC-prelim-title29-section1104 [4] U.S. Department of Labor, Understanding Your Fiduciary Responsibilities Under a Group Health Plan. https://www.dol.gov/agencies/ebsa/about-ebsa/our-activities/resource-center/publications/understanding-your-fiduciary-responsibilities-under-a-group-health-plan [5] Dickinson Wright, “Why Establish a Fiduciary Committee for Welfare Benefit Plans?” April 2024. https://hr.dickinson-wright.com/2024/04/15/why-establish-a-fiduciary-committee-for-welfare-benefit-plans/ [6] Order Granting Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss, Navarro v. Wells Fargo & Company, No. 24-cv-3043 (D. Minn. Mar. 3, 2026); Opinion, Lewandowski v. Johnson & Johnson, No. 24-671 (D.N.J. Nov. 26, 2025); Johnson & Johnson, 2025 Form 10-K (reporting final judgment and appeal). https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/minnesota/mndce/0:2024cv03043/218287/99/ ; https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/new-jersey/njdce/3%3A2024cv00671/540118/84/ ; https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/200406/000020040626000016/jnj-20251228.htm ; Notice of Appeal, Navarro v. Wells Fargo & Company, No. 26-1620 (8th Cir., filed Apr. 1, 2026); Stern v. JPMorgan Chase & Co., No. 1:25-cv-02097 (S.D.N.Y. Mar. 9, 2026); Jones Day, “Rising Scrutiny of Employer Health Plan Administration,” May 2026. https://litigationtracker.law.georgetown.edu/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/Navarro_2026.04.01_PLAINTIFFS-NOTICE-OF-APPEAL.pdf ; https://www.jonesday.com/en/insights/2026/05/rising-scrutiny-of-employer-health-plan-administration-erisa-fiduciary-litigation-federal-transparency-initiatives-state ; Cunningham v. Cornell University, 604 U.S. 693 (2025). https://www.supremecourt.gov/docket/docketfiles/html/public/23-1007.html [7] 29 U.S.C. §§ 1108(b)(2)(C), 1185o, as amended by the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2026. https://uscode.house.gov/us/usc/119-121/t29/s1108/ ; https://uscode.house.gov/us/usc/119-121/t29/s1185o/ [8] U.S. Department of Labor, “Improving Transparency Into Pharmacy Benefit Manager Fee Disclosure,” proposed rule, Jan. 30, 2026; Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs, RIN 1210-AB37, Final Rule Stage. https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2026/01/30/2026-01907/improving-transparency-into-pharmacy-benefit-manager-fee-disclosure ; https://www.reginfo.gov/public/do/eAgendaViewRule?RIN=1210-AB37&pubId=202510 [9] U.S. Department of Labor, Field Assistance Bulletin No. 2021-03. https://www.dol.gov/agencies/ebsa/employers-and-advisers/guidance/field-assistance-bulletins/2021-03 [10] Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Gag Clause Prohibition Compliance Attestation. https://www.cms.gov/marketplace/about/oversight/other-insurance-protections/gag-clause-prohibition-compliance-attestation [11] Federal Trade Commission, “Specialty Generic Drugs: A Growing Profit Center for Vertically Integrated Pharmacy Benefit Managers,” Second Interim Staff Report, January 2025. https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/ftc_gov/pdf/PBM-6b-Second-Interim-Staff-Report.pdf

This article is general information, not legal advice. Rules vary by plan type and state.