Business Insurance
Cyber Just Became the Newest Argument for Consolidation
In January, Coalition opened a dedicated private equity practice built around cyber risk. In June, Resilience followed with its own version, pairing a cyber risk platform called Arc with bespoke insurance endorsements aimed squarely at Private Equity (PE) sponsors and their portfolio companies. Seven months apart, two of the more active names in cyber underwriting decided the same thing at the same time: private equity portfolio companies need cyber coverage built as a program, not bought one company at a time.
We’ve watched this exact shift happen before, just not in cyber. For years, the firms I’ve worked with have run D&O, EPL, and fiduciary coverage as coordinated programs across a portfolio. One carrier writes the same form for every company. Pricing and terms get negotiated once and applied consistently. Renewal dates get synced so the whole portfolio moves together instead of ten companies chasing ten separate deadlines on ten separate calendars. Cyber sat outside that structure for a long time. It got bought the way a standalone private company buys it: one policy, one broker, no connection to anything else the fund owns.
That’s changed over the last eighteen to twenty-four months, and it’s changed for a reason that has nothing to do with insurance marketing. Kroll surveyed more than 300 private equity executives this year and found the average financial impact of a cyber incident at a portfolio company runs $2.1 million, with some incidents costing as much as $10 million. A number like that doesn’t stay contained to one line item on one company’s balance sheet. It touches the fund’s return on that investment, and increasingly, it touches how the fund gets underwritten and priced across every other company it holds.
Portfolio companies are also more exposed than most standalone businesses realize. They tend to be mid-sized and resource-constrained, which makes them attractive targets precisely because they don’t have the security budget of a public company, yet often sit on data, systems, or customer relationships worth attention from an attacker’s perspective.
In other words, a fund with ten portfolio companies isn’t managing one cyber risk. It’s managing ten, with ten different levels of maturity, ten different IT teams, and until recently, ten completely disconnected insurance programs to match.
For a long time, that was just accepted as how cyber worked. A portfolio company would get acquired, keep whatever cyber policy it already had or go find a new one on its own, and nobody at the fund level had real visibility into what any of it actually covered. Ask a CFO what their portfolio’s combined cyber exposure looks like and, until recently, you’d usually get a shrug. Not because they didn’t care, but because the market genuinely wasn’t set up to answer that question. There was no single carrier relationship to ask, no shared claims history to look back on, no way to see the whole picture at once.
Courtney Mauge, who leads cyber and E&O for our team, put it plainly when we were talking through what’s changed. “Cyber underwriters have traditionally evaluated portfolio companies one network at a time. We’ve challenged the market to step back and see the forest and not just the tree. By underwriting the portfolio holistically, carriers can influence behavior from the top down, elevate security standards across the organization, and build a stronger, better-performing book supported by the full premium opportunity, not just individual risks.”
That’s the real shift. Cyber risk itself didn’t change so much as carriers finally built the infrastructure to underwrite it the way sophisticated buyers had been asking for.
What a real program looks like isn’t complicated, even if it took the market a while to get here. Every portfolio company keeps its own policy, sized to its own risk. The terms are pre-negotiated once, with the same carrier, so a company added to the portfolio next year isn’t starting from zero. Claims data gets shared back to the fund level, so patterns that would be invisible looking at one company in isolation become obvious across ten. And when a claim happens, and eventually one will, the fund isn’t discovering for the first time whether its portfolio company’s forensic response team, its breach counsel, and its notification obligations are actually covered the way everyone assumed.
Something else we’ve seen play out more than once: funds that already run coordinated D&O and EPL programs adopt this faster, because they’ve already built the muscle. They know what it means to negotiate once and apply it across a portfolio, and they know what questions to ask a carrier before a claim happens instead of after. Funds still buying cyber one company at a time are usually the same ones still buying management liability one company at a time, and they’re starting to notice both problems have the same fix.
None of this means every portfolio company needs identical coverage. A healthcare portfolio company handling protected health information carries a different exposure than a manufacturing company worried about business interruption from a ransomware shutdown. A program structure doesn’t flatten those differences. It means the fund isn’t relearning the same lessons at every single company and isn’t discovering gaps between what the portfolio company bought on its own and what the fund itself actually needs at the moment a claim happens.
We’ve been building portfolio-level programs across management liability for years, largely because our clients asked for it before the broader market caught up to them. Cyber is the line where the gap between what sophisticated buyers wanted and what the market was set up to deliver has closed the fastest, and it’s closed in less time than most people in this business expected. Coalition and Resilience launching dedicated PE practices within months of each other isn’t a coincidence. It’s confirmation that the buyers were right all along, and the carriers finally caught up to what a portfolio actually needs. We think that same logic extends further than management liability and cyber. Benefits programs across a portfolio raise a similar set of questions, and that’s worth its own conversation.
If your portfolio companies are still buying cyber coverage independently of each other, this is a reasonable moment to ask why. The market that used to make that the only option doesn’t really exist anymore.
Julio Bermudez leads the Private Equity practice within Relation Insurance Services’ Financial Lines Group, advising private equity firms and their portfolio companies on management liability and cyber programs built to hold up across an entire portfolio, not just one company at a time.
